Drones vs. Fireworks: Can They Really Replace the Real Thing?

Click to Download the Full Publication

For many of us, fireworks are the soundtrack of summer. They light up our skies on Canada Day, energize community festivals, and mark cultural milestones with booming brilliance. But in recent years, some cities and towns have begun exploring drones as a high-tech alternative to traditional fireworks.

So, can a drone show truly deliver the same magic and connection that fireworks have offered for centuries?

Let’s take a closer look.

Fireworks: A Full-Sensory Celebration

Fireworks create a powerful, multi-sensory experience. We don’t just watch them—we hear the explosive booms, feel the concussive energy in our chest, smell the smoke drifting through the air, and see the brilliant colours dancing overhead. It’s not just visual; it’s physical and emotional. Drones, by comparison, provide only a visual display. While they can be synchronized to music and perform creative patterns in the sky, the experience lacks the depth and visceral thrill of a traditional fireworks show.

More Than Just a Light Show

For generations, fireworks have been tied to cultural and community tradition. Whether it’s celebrating Diwali, Lunar New Year, or Canada Day, fireworks hold a special place in the hearts of people around the world. The shared anticipation, the crowd’s collective reaction, and the powerful finale that shakes the ground—these are all part of the enduring magic. Drones, while novel and interesting, simply don’t evoke the same emotional response. The impact just isn’t the same.

When Technology Meets Reality

The logistics of organizing a drone show are far more complex than they might appear. Unlike fireworks, which can be launched from a single secure location with clearly defined fallout zones, drones require two separate staging areas: one for takeoff and return, and another for the aerial display itself. This setup often needs much more space and infrastructure than a traditional fireworks show.

Drone shows are also highly sensitive to weather. Even light wind or rain can delay or cancel a drone performance entirely. Fireworks, on the other hand, can usually be launched in a wider range of conditions, making them a more dependable option.

And then there’s the cost. A drone light show can cost nearly three times more per minute than a traditional fireworks display. On average, two drones are lost per show—adding to the already high expense of equipment, battery charging, and programming.

Visibility and Viewer Experience

One of the great things about fireworks is that there’s no bad seat in the house. Their explosive displays are visible from all angles and distances, creating a three-dimensional experience that includes both visual and physical impact. People feel the booms, see the bursts, and are immersed in the moment—no matter where they’re standing.

With drone shows, viewers need to be in a specific location to appreciate the performance fully. The experience is more limited, more directional, and far less likely to produce that unforgettable “wow” factor that fireworks naturally create.

Are Drones Really Greener?

It’s often claimed that drones are a more environmentally friendly option, but the truth is more complicated. In Canada, more than 4,000 fireworks are tested each year to meet stringent government safety and environmental standards. If the materials were considered dangerous to human health or the environment, they wouldn’t be approved for public use.

Drones, by contrast, rely on lithium-ion batteries, which are made using minerals mined from the earth. The production and disposal of these batteries, along with the electronic components that make up the drones themselves, contribute to environmental degradation and add to global e-waste.

What About Public Sentiment?

Many people expect and look forward to fireworks as part of a celebration. They’re familiar, loved, and deeply connected to our sense of occasion. Swapping them out for drones can leave audiences disappointed. While drones may impress some, others walk away feeling that something was missing.

In addition, there are growing concerns around the use of drones from a psychological standpoint. With their use in modern warfare, particularly in recent conflicts in the Middle East and Eastern Europe, the sound of drones can be triggering for some newcomers to Canada. Several individuals have reported that the high-pitched noise reminds them of the warfare they fled, creating fear and discomfort rather than joy and celebration. It’s essential to consider the lived experiences of all community members when planning public events.

Why Some Communities Are Reversing Course

Cities like Montreal, Sudbury, and Timmins, Ontario, have reversed their decisions to replace fireworks with drones. Montreal reported that drone shows were up to five times more expensive than traditional fireworks, making them unsustainable for large-scale events. Logistical complications, such as securing exemptions for drone operations in busy airspace, added further barriers.

In Timmins, local leaders and residents welcomed the return of fireworks. They emphasized that fireworks bring people together in a way that drones simply don’t. The festive atmosphere, the sense of occasion, and the sheer excitement that fireworks deliver are unmatched.

The Final Word

There’s no doubt that drone shows are creative and intriguing—but they’re not a full replacement for fireworks. Fireworks deliver a unique, multi-sensory experience, steeped in cultural tradition and emotional impact. They’re more accessible, more affordable, and more reliable, especially for large community celebrations.

Drones may have a role to play in the future of public events, but for now, fireworks remain the enduring crowd favourite—lighting up the sky and connecting us through shared wonder and celebration.